Who deserves to live?

On the face of it I expect most people would reply to the question of “who deserves to live”, with an obvious and emphatic, “everyone”. However, when you really start looking around and listening to what people say, or more importantly don’t say, it becomes clear that this is actually not entirely the case. 

The COVID-19 pandemic has in many ways brought us together more closely than ever before and has served to highlight our interconnectedness. Though there are examples to the contrary, our societal response has generally been one that has included a huge outpouring of supportive sentiment and an awareness of and preference towards, doing what is best for the group, rather than the individual.

Meanwhile, for many people in our communities, people who live with and at times struggle with substance use and complex needs related to substance addiction, COVID has cast a large shadow over their needs and pushed them even farther to the margins of society. 

According to Toronto Public Health, there has been an increase of 85% in suspected opioid-overdose-related deaths during COVID-19 compared to the monthly averages from the same period in 2019. There were 27 deaths in July alone, the highest ever recorded since this type of data has been collected. April and May also had 25 deaths each per month. Anyone can see this data on the City of Toronto’s website if they choose to look.  So, if overdoses have claimed so many lives throughout COVID-19, why do we not see more about it in the news?

We believe it is because of the extreme stigma surrounding trauma and substance use, which has a narrative that goes something like this: “everything possible should be done to combat COVID because anyone can get it through no fault of their own and while overdoses are unfortunate, people have a choice.” Again, We would stress that this narrative is not always spoken, but it is almost always implied. The irreducibly complex collection of experiences that can lead a person to poverty, homelessness and substance use are ultimately, and paradoxically, reduced to a simple statement that ‘people have a choice’.

Which brings us back to where we started: who deserves to live? Because the uncomfortable truth is that the implication of a statement such as ‘people have a choice’, is that the person ultimately deserves the consequences of their choice. A modern take on ‘you reap what you sow’. You use dangerous injection opioids? Well then you risk dying and if you do, well, that’s the consequence to your choice. This hopefully sounds awful to you but if you spend any time reading the comment sections on articles related to the homelessness or opioid crises happening in our communities, you’ll see that unfortunately this attitude is shockingly common. You’ll see that the entirety of a person’s existence –their spirit and uniqueness, their aspirations and their fears – is quickly dismissed by a label of ‘addict’ or ‘junkie’.

The opioid crisis and the trend of lethal overdoses that accompany it are complicated and while there is not one quick and easy singular thing that can be done – there are solutions. Lots of them in fact, but they take time and resources and, most importantly, empathy and compassion. They take people like you to ask the question – why are so many people dying needlessly in our communities? Why aren’t we talking about this? Why aren’t we doing more?

People who use drugs are just that – people. They have flaws and challenges and their actions can be disruptive but they are human beings – our neighbours, our sons and daughters, sisters and brothers, parents and friends. They are people who deserve to live and who need our help. We need to have the courage to explore new systemic responses to the opioid crisis and accept that some of them are going to challenge some of our traditional beliefs and society norms. We need to be open to change in ourselves and in our communities. For those who ask – “yes but what can I do?” An easy way to start is to call or email your local City Councilor and ask them to do more to combat the overdose crisis. Tell them that you think people deserve to live. You can follow St Felix Centre’s social media platforms to learn more about ways that you can help.

At St Felix Centre, aside from the more tangible services we deliver each day, our primary goal is to give people hope. The people to whom we provide these services and support are disproportionately impacted by the opioid and overdose crises, and we work each day to help to restore hope to them. We need your help – our extended community – to show our guests, those who we support, that they deserve to live.

Senior Leadership Team, St. Felix Centre.

Share this post